Enriching lives

Short Shortt Review

Home » News » Shortt Review
AMC Rupert Shortt

Ken Harris and Angela Smith caught the mood of our Good Faith Book Club's discussion of Rupert Shortt's book.

Ken writes, "The title of the book 'Does Religion Do More Harm Than Good' is an important one for our age when religion seems to be under attack, so I had looked forward to reading it. But I was extremely disappointed and even angry with what felt to me to be a failure to really explore the ways in which religion can and does cause both harm and good. While I was not expecting a mathematical answer, I was looking for an informed discussion of what was good about religion and what was not good. Instead I got lost in a philosophic presentation that I did not really understand even after reading the book twice. This is not a book I could recommend to anyone."

Angela writes: "While reading, "Does Religion Do More Harm Than Good" by Rupert Shortt, I filled two sides of A4 paper, with the words I could not understand and the names of people I had never heard of, who were mentioned in the book. I then referred to my dictionary and the internet, but in spite of my studies, I'm afraid, I could still not explain to anyone, how the existence of God could be supported by the " modal ontological argument, the kalam cosmological argument or the arguments from moral truths, mathematical truths or from consciousness". I would not recommend this book to a non-academic reader."

popular recent storiesAlso in the news

Thought For
Geoff Short: Fri 16 Apr 5:00am

Geoff continues our thoughts from Isaiah with a word about feet from Isaiah 52:7-10.7 How beautiful on the mountains are the feet of those who bring good news, who proclaim peace, who bring good tidings, who proclaim salvation, who say to Zion, "Your God reigns!" 8 Listen! Your watchmen lift up their voices; together they shout for joy. When the LORD returns to Zion, they will see it...

AMC Street angels
Aylesbury Town Chaplaincy: Thu 15 Apr 12:00pm

Andrew Henderson, Chair of Aylesbury Town Chaplaincy, opens their annual report by saying: We have an ongoing commitment to our town and our community and are here to support, encourage and serve all those who work, live in or visit our town.This year has, as for the whole world, not been as we expected at the start of the year. For the first 2 and a half months it was very much business as...

Thought For
Pete Honeyaball: Thu 15 Apr 5:00am

Pete finds words of comfort in Isaiah 40:1-11 from 2,500 years ag that are very relevant today.Comfort for God's People1 Comfort, comfort my people, says your God. 2 Speak tenderly to Jerusalem, and proclaim to her that her hard service has been completed, that her sin has been paid for, that she has received from the LORD's hand double for all her sins. 3 A voice of one calling:...