Enriching lives

Short Shortt Review

Home » News » Shortt Review
AMC Rupert Shortt

Ken Harris and Angela Smith caught the mood of our Good Faith Book Club's discussion of Rupert Shortt's book.

Ken writes, "The title of the book 'Does Religion Do More Harm Than Good' is an important one for our age when religion seems to be under attack, so I had looked forward to reading it. But I was extremely disappointed and even angry with what felt to me to be a failure to really explore the ways in which religion can and does cause both harm and good. While I was not expecting a mathematical answer, I was looking for an informed discussion of what was good about religion and what was not good. Instead I got lost in a philosophic presentation that I did not really understand even after reading the book twice. This is not a book I could recommend to anyone."

Angela writes: "While reading, "Does Religion Do More Harm Than Good" by Rupert Shortt, I filled two sides of A4 paper, with the words I could not understand and the names of people I had never heard of, who were mentioned in the book. I then referred to my dictionary and the internet, but in spite of my studies, I'm afraid, I could still not explain to anyone, how the existence of God could be supported by the " modal ontological argument, the kalam cosmological argument or the arguments from moral truths, mathematical truths or from consciousness". I would not recommend this book to a non-academic reader."

popular recent storiesAlso in the news

AMC Ken A 5
Posted: Mon 27 Jan 5:00am

We have just heard that Ken Anderson passed away peacefully on 22nd January, surrounded by his family. He was 92. Ken had Alzheimer's and has had a difficult couple of years as a result, becoming very frail. He was a much-loved and appreciated Supernumerary Minister in this church and circuit. About 10 years ago, following the death of his wife Meg, he emigrated to Australia to be with his...

AMC Rev RA Street Angels
Posted: Fri 24 Jan 5:00am

An inspirational new Prayer and Action Guide has been produced by CNI (Christian Nightlife Initiatives) and several of its local projects and partner organisations, including here in Aylesbury.The Guide is based on the work of local Street Angels, Club Angels and Festival Angels who see how prayer and action can and does change communities and people. The 30 day Guide was produced to help...

AMC WDP 2020
Jackie Simpson - Tyda: Thu 23 Jan 5:00am

I am representing AMC on the World Day of Prayer (WDP) committee. The 2020 service has been prepared by the women of Zimbabwe and will be presented in 170 countries throughout the world on one day — Friday 6th March. There are two services: one in the afternoon at 1.30pm (at the 7th Day Adventist Church on the Stoke Road), and the evening one at 7.30pm at the Lady of Lourdes Catholic Church...