Contact
Streaming
Map
 
Enriching lives

Book Club Review

Home » News » Book Club Review
8C65FF8F-DF63-4642-802F-19B2427AADF5

'A Heart Broken Open' is Rev Ray Gaston's account of his engagement with Islam in the majority Muslim population of the Inner City Leeds parish in which he ministered for twelve years. Views of the book were mixed with most people of the opinion that it was tough going, somewhat repetitive, inward-looking and intense. Despite that, it stimulated interesting and far-reaching discussion.
Gaston made a good case for pacifism in his book and explained the differences between the Sunni and Shia branches of Islam clearly. He also reminded us of, probably, the earliest example of a mutually respectful Christian-Muslim Interfaith dialogue almost 900 years ago when St Francis and Sultan Al-Kamil met during the time of the Fifth Crusade in 1219.
We noted from Gaston's account that his efforts to reach out to his Muslim neighbours appeared one-sided, lacking reciprocity from the Islamic community with which he sought to engage. We considered possible reasons for this, drawing on our own experiences of Muslim people we have encountered here in Aylesbury, which were overwhelmingly positive, open and friendly.
Our conversation then moved on to similarities and differences between Christianity and Islam. We discussed the way in which both faiths had split early in their histories over matters of authority, and both struggled with how to interpret ancient scripture in a way that was meaningful to 21st century people. We discussed our responses to the hijab, Ramadan, and the rationale behind some Islamic men (in specific times and places) having up to four wives. We talked about how Muslims appeared to know their faith better that Christians, in general, know theirs, and we wondered about the reasons for that — if indeed it was true. Was it because Islam is more straightforward; because children were taught their religion systematically from a young age; or because Muslim scripture is always read in the original Arabic avoiding the complication of translations?
Exploring different understandings of our own faith alone, we concluded that Christianity certainly is a very complex religion. We had no reason to believe Islam would be any different. We also recognised that culture, as well as belief, plays a huge part in creating the differences between our respective faiths. We can't all think alike, nevertheless we can all love alike.
We ended our time together reflecting on how far we individually would feel comfortable engaging with another faith: dialogue alone, observing prayers and worship, praying together (perhaps in a language we did not understand), fasting, or otherwise participating in faith-specific rituals ...? We each had our own cut-off point. What we all agreed, however, was that engagement was helpful and that the School of Love, into which Christians and Muslims alike have all been enrolled, requires us, and reticence notwithstanding, challenges us, to pursue that engagement in the interests of mutual respect and understanding.
Our next meeting is on Saturday 25 March. We will be discussing Rob Bell's latest book "What is the Bible?" I can vouch for the fact that newbies are made very welcome at the Book Club and I am pretty certain that you won't be required to write the notes of the meeting unless you, like me, are rash enough to offer to do so!

Karen Crussell

popular recent storiesAlso in the news

Thought For
Rev. Richard Atkinson: Wed 27 Jan 5:00am

Continuing our look at the letter to the Hebrews by an unknown writer, Richard reflects on superheroes and the humanity of Jesus, together with Hebrews 2:5-17.Jesus Made Fully Human5 It is not to angels that he has subjected the world to come, about which we are speaking. 6 But there is a place where someone has testified: "What is mankind that you are mindful of them, a son of man...

Thought For
Frankie Fisher: Tue 26 Jan 5:00am

Today, Frankie grapples with Hebrews 1:5-12.Jesus Made Fully Human5 It is not to angels that he has subjected the world to come, about which we are speaking. 6 But there is a place where someone has testified: "What is mankind that you are mindful of them, a son of man that you care for him? 7 You made them a little lower than the angels; you crowned them with glory and honor 8 and put...

AMC Bad Christian
Peter Green: Mon 25 Jan 12:00pm

The Good Faith Book Club's have chosen How to be a bad Christian and a better human being by Dave Tomlinson as their next book. The blurb says:"In the course of his work as a vicar, Dave Tomlinson meets lots of people who describe themselves as 'not good enough' to be a Christian, thinking that faith involves going to church a lot, or believing in a list of strange things, or...